Category Archives: Advertising

The next opportunity for online video – a technology provider’s view

Last week Journalism.co.uk attended a roundtable discussion about the future of video – for publishers, journalists and advertisers. Those gathered around the table, including representatives from the BBC, the Financial Times, the Economist and Thomson Reuters, were adamant that online video news and analysis is an important part of the multimedia mix and can be a source of revenue for “publisher broadcasters”.

Contrast this view with that of several regional website editors I spoke with at a recent meeting of the Digital Editors Network in Preston: investment in kit and training done, many admitted they’d axed news channel-style video on their websites, because of a lack of demand and now resources to keep it up. Some admitted their approach to video had been wrong – e.g. trying to replicate TV bulletins on a newspaper website – while others said dwindling resources had removed video from their web priorities’ list.

But there is clearly demand from advertisers and viewers for web video as a format – look no further than YouTube and the week’s latest viral videos.

And those providing the technology and options for advertisers to get involved are part of a burgeoning market if an announcement today from Videoplaza, which provides technology for serving up ads in and around online video, is anything to go by: the Scandinavian company has secured a $5 million investment round.

The investment will mean that Videoplaza, which already works with Incisive Media and myvideorights.com in the UK and La Vanguardia in Spain, can expand into new markets – both geographically and technologically, founder and CEO Sorosh Tavakoli told Journalism.co.uk yesterday.

This week the company signed its first Russian client and moves into Germany and further expansion in the UK and southern Europe are also on the shopping list, he says.

When it comes to making money from video on new platforms, publishers need to be prepared and have the options in place to take advantage of these new screens and viewers when they reach critical mass, he explains, adding that Videoplaza has been working with publishers to produce business plans for their video strategies to show to management where the money lies.

“I think there’s only a few carefully selected publishers who are seeing return on video. There’s a lot do and only part of that do we help them with and that’s the technology. But technology is an enabler in the end,” he says.

“We have experience from a lot of different clients in a lot of different markets so we can help our publishers come up with a lot of interesting packaging strategies, for example, working with a local newspaper, we’re not working with Proctor & Gamble and national ads, we have to do something more creative that will get the local car dealership on board.”

Key to Videoplaza’s strategy is making clients look at where video fits in with their wider business strategy. As such, the firm helped one radio station customer to develop an in-house video production service for advertisers, using their existing resources; elsewhere, with a TV client, a system has been developed where TV programme sponsors must sponsor related content online – a good example of helping advertisers bridge the gap between old and new media, says Tavakoli adds.

Sometimes with video advertising ideas you have to go backwards and educate advertisers and clients rather than push them into ‘the next big thing’ – creativity can then be sneaked in, he adds. Video advertising can be disruptive by its very nature, he says, and creating a good user experience while making as much money for the publishers as possible is a difficult balance to strike. One solution the company has introduced to a client is the option for viewers to turn off a pre-roll ad on videos after seven seconds – giving the user control, but the publisher’s advertiser a guaranteed timeslot.

But perhaps more significantly the company wants to use fresh investment to develop its products for ‘new tv’ – the myriad of screens and platforms through which people are now viewing online video and in particular the idea of connected TV. While there may only be a few publishers currently seeing returns on their investment in video, with ‘new TV’ comes new opportunities, says Tavakoli. The firm has already experimented with some forms of interactive advertising on La Vanguardia’s mobile videos and Sweden’s TV4 iPhone app.

We see a big change in consumption of video from ‘old TV’ to ‘new TV’, where the old TV is a big black box that receives a broadcasted signal that everyone else receives as well; where new TV is something a bit more unique and screen independent and more plentiful in terms of types of content. The ‘new TV’ needs an advertising platform built for it and we’re trying to build that platform.

From the publisher’s perspective – here’s Stephen Pinches from the FT on opportunities for publishers and IPTV:

FT.com: WPP develops technology to police web ad placements

GroupM Interaction, the media agency of WPP, is hoping to overcome the problem of misplaced ads online with a new monitoring technology. Advertising networks which place aggregate banned adverts for clients across a range of sites may create clashes between the ad and editorial content placed elsewhere on the site – an oil company’s ad next to a news story on climate change, for example, the FT reports.

GroupM Interaction (…) is hoping to prevent such incidents by using “ad verification” technology, which reports back on which sites client messages are being shown, and in some cases even prevents them from appearing if the site is considered unsuitable.

Full story at this link…

allmediascotland: Scottish government drops plans to remove public notices from newspapers

The Scottish government has scrapped its plans for legislation, which would have allowed local authorities to place public notices solely on the internet. The proposals had been heavily criticised by representatives of the local press, who feared the legislation would cut off a much-needed revenue stream.

But the fight from local authorities isn’t over – a spokesperson for the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities says the portal for public notices will still go ahead and evidence to support the future introduction of such legislation will be gathered.

Full story at this link…

TechCrunch: Newspapers have never made much money from news, says Google’s chief economist

TechCrunch has a summary of a presentation by Google’s chief economist, Hal Varian, on the decline of newspaper advertising revenues.

“The fact of the matter is that newspapers have never made much money from news,” says Varian. They make money from “special interest sections on topics such as Automotive, Travel, Home & Garden, Food & Drink, and so on.” The problem is that on the web, other niche sites which cater to those categories are a click away, leaving the newspapers with sections which are harder to sell ads against, such as sports, news, and local.

Full post at this link…

Presentation below:

030910 Hal Varian FTC Preso

Media Release: Social networks to fall under Advertising Standards Authority’s remit

The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) could see its remit extended to cover marketing activity on companies’ websites and social networks, it was announced yesterday.

Says the Advertising Association’s (AA) release, which can be downloaded at this link:

The Advertising Association (AA) has submitted the industry’s recommendations to the Committee of Advertising Practice (CAP), for the extension of the non-broadcast Advertising Code in digital media, which will be administered by the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA). This landmark move for advertising self-regulation seeks to address societal concerns and will increase protection for consumers and children.

Marketing communications activity in paid-for space online is already covered by ASA. But the extended remit could come into force by Q3 2010.

A release from the ASA states:

Currently, the ASA’s online remit covers paid-for marketing communications such as pop-up and banner ads, paid-search and viral ads. However, nearly two thirds of the complaints that we receive about online marketing activity are not presently covered by the code. The proposed extension of our remit will plug this regulatory gap, ensuring that consumers enjoy the same level of protection on websites as they do in paid-for space.

Forbes.com: US advertisers will spend more on digital than print in 2010

According to a study from Outsell released yesterday, US advertisers are spending more on digital media than print in 2010.

Outsell’s annual advertising and marketing study, which collected data from 1,0008 US advertisers relating to their planned spend for 2010, suggests that 32.5 per cent of a total $368 billion ad spend will go on digital – email, video ads, online display and search marketing – and 30.3 per cent on print.

But marketers will spend 16 per cent less on mobile in 2010, the report suggests.

Full story at this link…

BIA/Kelsey Blog: Associated Content CEO – ‘local is a differentiator’

The ‘open content network’ Associated Content is looking to own more localised event content with advertising, its CEO told BIA/Kelsey in an interview for its blog.

Associated Content, which has over 350,000 contributors (and 60 employees),  gathers and syndicates content around the web. CEO Patrick Keane told BIA/Kelsey that the company can also develop content on a “custom” basis for commercial clients, which it has done for Reuters, Hachette, Procter & Gamble and Toyota.

Publishers – who Keane calls “the owners of audience” – can increasingly see the value of unique content creation assets, he says. AOL, for instance, owns less than 10 percent of its content. Yahoo’s percentage of ownership may not be much higher.

For such sites, local content is a key differentiator, especially since so much of it has a utility angle. We see more and more contributors contributing content on a localised basis, says Keane. Consequently, one of Associated Content’s big initiatives is to find, discern and empower contributors on the basis of local DNA.

Full post at this link…

Rob Grimshaw on the paywall backlash

FT.com managing director Rob Grimshaw, regular spokesperson for the paid-for content model,  has a real problem with the language used by critics of the paywall, he told Journalism.co.uk yesterday.

“It’s always put into pejorative terms.” he said, “It doesn’t happen to any other product: you don’t talk about restaurants giving people a bad user experience by giving them a bill at the end of it.

“It’s understood that something has been produced and it needs to be paid for; somehow with news content it has become a totally different argument,” he said.

It is almost regarded as a “sort of a criminal act to have the temerity to charge for some of our products,” Grimshaw added. “It’s something that we need to get away from.”

“We’re not a charity, we’re a company with shareholders: there’s nothing free about the information we produce – our editorial operation costs millions of pounds to run and we don’t see it’s odd to put a price on it. In fact, it’s probably the only way to run a reasonable business.”

Needless to say, he supports the NYT’s newly announced FT-style subscription model, scheduled for 2011: “Publishers need to get themselves out the hole and be a bit more bold and brassy,” he said.

Publishers shouldn’t, he added, be afraid to say their content has got a value. While he admitted the FT has a niche and affluent reader base for its subscriber model, he believes general news sites can do it as well.

“Our sense [is that] if other publishers do go for it, they will be able to build successful models.”

FT.com is not without its free content rivals, he said: “[W]e’re not short of competition – for every topic we cover on FT.com you can find a list of sites as long as your arm.”

“There are parallels between what we’re doing and what general news publishers will have to do as well. For me, the big thing is quality. It all comes back to quality. Whether it’s niche [or not] it’s got to be good”.

General news sites have the capability, brand and long heritage with which to build better quality sites, Grimshaw argued. They can be “far more compelling than one man blogging in a room,” he said.

“There are numerous ways that publishers can create sites which people are prepared to pay for because they are better than anything else that’s out there.

“I don’t see that the publishers are going to have trouble to get their users to pay for content.”

Grimshaw’s firm belief, as he has said before, is that newspapers cannot  live by advertising alone.

Citing IAB figures from last year (available at this link), he said it was paid-for search that took “by far” the bulk of the money: around 62 per cent; with 19 per cent to classified; and only 18 per cent to online advertising spend.

“It seems everybody in the whole world is trying to float their business on that [advertising model]. It’s just not big enough for every one of those businesses  (…) so something is going to have to give.

“Either publishers are going to find themselves in serious difficulties, or they’re going to have to come up with another way of making money.”

FT.com’s forthcoming content plans include a new Blackberry app, ‘one day pass’ subscriptions, and video for iPhone.

Read more about it on our main site.

Folio: Hearst develops web ads for printed pages

Web ads will not be lost on articles printed out from websites thanks to a new development from Hearst Digital Media and Format Dynamics.

The CleanPrint service, which will be put into action on GoodHousekeeping.com and soon spread to Esquire and Cosmopolitan’s US websites, will provide new opportunities to advertisers:

[B]oth a “re-messaging” opportunity or a separate, contextual placement at the point of printout. Most often, using the “print” function on a web page to obtain a hardcopy eliminates the banner ads altogether.

In cases where new ads are created for printouts: “The ads only appear when the pages are printed, with the theory that users who print the page are inherently committed to the content.”

Full story at this link…

AdAge.com: Monetising news tweets

Advertising Age takes a look at ways of making money out of your news organisations’ tweets, pointing to Ad.ly, a start-up offering paid tweets among news tweets.

Another example given is Canoe, a news publisher based in Montreal:

Since last month, it’s used a service from Assetize that inserts an advertising bar on top of pages that get shouted out in participating Twitter feeds.

Full post at this link…