Yesterday we reported on the BBC Trust ruling that Panorama had broken editorial guidelines of fairness and accuracy in its programme Primark: On The Rack.
The BBC was ordered to make an on-air apology over the documentary, which was broadcast in June 2008, after the Trust said the programme contained footage that was likely not genuine.
Roy Greenslade said the Trust’s decision was “baffling”.
It goes against natural justice to find against the journalist and producers on what it calls “the balance of probabilities.”
Dan McDougall is an intrepid, award-winning investigative reporter with a superb record in exposing human rights violations.
Frank Simmonds is an experienced producer who has been responsible for many important revelatory Panorama programmes.
Yet this so-called judgment – which requires the corporation to apologise for the documentary – puts a black mark against their names on the most tenuous of grounds.
Having studied the report, I believe the Trust has got this wholly wrong.