Bill Keller has responded to the New York Times’ public editor’s unflinching critique of errors made in a piece about Walter Cronkite by Alessandra Stanley, as part of a Q&A with James Rainey from the LA Times, published in full on Editor & Publisher.
Keller suggests that the public editor’s position is still ‘much debated’:
Q: Has the public editor helped build the Times’ reputation, or done more to knock the paper’s reputation down? It may help to address this question both as it pertains to this particular episode and, more generally, over the brief history of public editorship.
A: On balance, I think the fact that we offer a paycheck and a platform to an independent critic to second-guess our journalistic judgments is good for, pardon the expression, the brand. I don’t always agree with our public editor, but I think he is fair-minded, his reporting is meticulous, and his targets – as in this case – are usually fair game. He doesn’t just blow raspberries. He tries to explain how bad things happen, and he reports what we are trying to do to avoid future mistakes. Whether a public editor should be a permanent, or at least continuing, fixture at The Times is a question much debated within our walls. I’ve kicked it down the road until we near the end of Clark’s term next year.
Journalism.co.uk is aware of full-time newspaper ombudsmen at the Guardian [Siobhain Butterworth] and the Observer [Stephen Pritchard] and yesterday learned that Sally Baker is feedback editor for the Times. Does anyone know of any other UK titles with full-time and independent readers’ editors? And do those without one need one?Tags: alessandra stanley, bill keller, clark hoyt, editor, Editor & Publisher, Editor&Publisher, feedback editor, independent critic, james rainey, Journalism.co.uk, LA Times, New York Times, Newspapers, ombudsmen, public editor, readers editor, Sally Baker, stephen pritchard, The Guardian, the LA Times, The Times, United Kingdom, Walter Cronkite
- NYTimes.com: Exec editor takes NYTimes reader questions
- NY Times exec ed Bill Keller sparks online comment with Darfur remark
- What format for the political leaders’ TV debates?
- Advancing The Story: The role of the ombudsman in a cash-strapped newsroom
- Independent: Reprint of Independent article leads to Indian newspaper editor’s arrest