Bivings’ top 10 US newspapers: missing the news point?

1 Reply

The Bivings Group‘s recently released Bivings Report of the top 10 US newspaper sites in 2008 consisted of:

  1. New York Times
  2. Washington Post
  3. Wall Street Journal
  4. Florida Times-Union
  5. Philadelphia Inquirer
  6. USA Today
  7. St Paul Pioneer Press
  8. Atlanta Journal-Constitution
  9. Arizona Republic
  10. Columbus Dispatch

The study, which picks the list based on usability, design and web features of the US’ 100 largest newspapers, is purposefully limited to covering US-based, newspaper sites.

But as one commenter on the Bivings blog says, ‘No Mention of any of MY best news sites’ – he then goes on to list his own top 10, including Huffington Post and EveryBlock (which another commenter then takes as the Bivings’ list).

Is comparing like-for-like really that useful – newspapers aren’t just competing with each other – or other mainstream news organisations – anymore. What the Bivings Group rates the sites on may be completely different from the readers’ criteria – particularly if these comments are anything to go by.

It reminds me of this Project for Excellence in Journalism (PEJ) study from 2007, which found a different news agenda on UGC sites than mainstream platforms (e.g the agenda decided by journalists).

Users’ online agendas are different (and that’s not to say news organisations should completely adhere to UGC inspired schedules – that’s a debate for another day) and influenced by a plethora of different online sources. As such their expectations of newspaper sites will be shaped by the other tools and information websites they use. Ranking newspaper websites against each other won’t deliver the kind of comparisons that these sites can take away and use.

1 thought on “Bivings’ top 10 US newspapers: missing the news point?”

  1. Todd Zeigler

    Hi Laura,

    I work at Bivings, and appreciate you reviewing our list and your comment. The point of our original research, of which this list is a bio-product, was to see how newspaper websites were keeping up with the challenge posed by upstarts like Digg, HuffPo, etc. Were they adding features in an effort to keep up? Are they learning lessons from these competing ways of presenting the news? You can review the findings here:

    http://www.bivingsreport.com/2008/the-use-of-the-internet-by-americas-largest-newspapers-2008-edition/

    The top 10 list is nothing more than a way for us to recognize the best sites of the ones that we looked at in our study.

    Thanks for your comment.

    Todd

Leave a Reply