You must not embed the Telegraph’s embeddable video
It might look like you can embed this Telegraph video on your blog:
But no: please take note of the last part.
As both Journalism.co.uk and Fred Hatman, a journalist in South Africa found out, embed codes are only for ‘personal use’. That didn’t include Hatman (@fredhatman) even though he is a lone blogger.
Instead, we had to feature the story of the Telegraph journalist who was attacked by a lion after willingly entering its enclosure (mauling received surprisingly cheerfully) without the accompanying video. We got permission to link though!
Syndication@telegraph.co.uk informs us:
“I’m afraid at this time we can’t grant permission for you to host the video, but you are welcome to link to it.”
So we asked them why they supplied the code? And how could we fulfil the requirements for a licence? They replied:
“My understanding is that this function is for personal use only, not for commercial use, as per our terms and conditions. Often we are able to issue a licence for the content, but on this occasion Telegraph.co.uk are not offering this video for web syndication.”
Journalism.co.uk wonders how Telegraph.co.uk will monitor and police misuse of the videos – if abuse was extensive. Or how they decide who is commercial and who is not? If, as the Syndication people tell us, ‘on this occasion Telegraph.co.uk are not offering this video for web syndication’ why bother supplying it at all? Isn’t that just asking for trouble?
Similar posts:
- BBCInternetBlog: BBC begins to roll out embed function on news videos
- Media Release: BBC Trust confirms permission refusal for BBC’s local video plans
- Telegraph journalist gets mauled in lion’s enclosure (video)
- MediaGuardian: ITV suspending ITN news on website
- Telegraph news recruits need to be commercially focused too, says new media director
Working in journalism and want to boost your digital skills? Questions about starting a news business online that you've been too afraid to ask?
September 11th, 2009 at 12:44 pm
Thank you, Judith, for clarifying this issue. Very interesting. I think it raises a much wider issue about copyright on digital content.
It would be helpful if there were some universal guidelines on what is usable or embeddable for both “commercial sites” and “lone bloggers” such as myself, who is yet to earn a penny from my blog.
But, of course, how can the amorphous and open-to-all worldwideweb, transcending national borders, be regulated and, indeed, enforced.
It is confusing, however, when a large news organisation such as the Telegraph, for whom – somewhat ironically – I worked for six years – allows embedding of videos and then demands that hosting rights be applied for.
I would be interested to read the thoughts of other journalists, both traditional and digital, on this.
Thank you for your help, Fred Hatman
September 12th, 2009 at 12:27 pm
I would imagine the terms and conditions were written long before the Telegraph started using embeddable video. Now that the BBC have started syndicating their own video – with conditions attached – to the Telegraph and others it’s probably prompting many news sites to look at their own Ts & Cs.
Adding the ‘To license this video clip…’ text is a half-arsed stopgap measure.
As an industry we need to shake this issue out. Either it’s in an organisation’s interests to increase viewership of its video by allowing embedding – in which case it makes sense to allow it on commercial sites which typically have more users – or it isn’t. Time to choose.
September 16th, 2009 at 1:25 am
[...] You must not embed the Telegraph’s embeddable video [...]
September 20th, 2009 at 8:04 pm
[...] You must not embed the Telegraph’s embeddable video – What happens when policy come second to technology. The Telegraph make a hash out of nothing… [...]
September 23rd, 2009 at 10:06 pm
[...] You must not embed the Telegraph’s embeddable video "Journalism.co.uk wonders how Telegraph.co.uk will monitor and police misuse of the videos – if abuse was extensive. Or how they decide who is commercial and who is not? If, as the Syndication people tell us, ‘on this occasion Telegraph.co.uk are not offering this video for web syndication’ why bother supplying it at all? Isn’t that just asking for trouble?" (tags: video copyright newspapers) Share this [...]