Andrew Keen: ‘The internet will devour newspapers’

Andrew Keen, writing on Telegraph.co.uk, reminds newspapers that they could be made redundant by the internet. Picking up a recent argument made by the author and academic Clay Shirky, Keen writes:

“The core reality of the internet is its absence of a centre. The distributed internet, all edge and no heart, has done away with the centralised structures of power of the old industrial world. And without a core, the news can’t be controlled by a central power. It can no longer be owned.

“The internet is like a blob, a centreless yet all powerful monster, impossible to destroy and yet able to devour everything in its path.”

Full post at this link…

Similar posts:

• Comment is Free: Marcel Berlins on the web’s encouragement of lies and deceit
• Jon Snow: ‘Being a good journalist takes your whole life’
• Greenslade: Mirror.co.uk on metrics and building loyal online audiences
• Heather Brooke thanks the Speaker for ‘making my career’ / Alan Keen update
• YourRightToKnow: Heather Brooke responds to MP Alan Keen’s questions

Clay Shirky: ‘Rescuing the reporters’

Taking his own local paper as the basis for his argument, Clay Shirky looks at why local news reporters need ‘a rescue operation’.

“There are dozen or so reporters and editors in Columbia, Missouri, whose daily and public work is critical to the orderly functioning of that town, and those people are trapped inside a burning business model,” he writes.

Newsrooms need to look at the people necessary to producing the ‘iron core of news’ (as defined by Alex Jones) and those who can’t be replace as easily as other areas of content, such as columns, suggests Shirky.

He goes on to argue that working for a non-profit news organisation will be an increasingly attractive option for these reporters as a result.

Full post at this link…

Similar posts:

• Mashable: Wikipedia’s new editorial layer
• Innovations in Journalism – Dapper
• AOP: Today’s television ‘may not be worth sitting still for’, says US author Clay Shirky
• Clay Shirky: The old model’s broken – don’t try to replace it
• Andrew Keen: ‘The internet will devour newspapers’

A journalistic limbo until we reach The New World

According to many, the perfect storm is approaching. The winds have been whipping for a while. But there’s a problem. The Old King is dying but the New King, apparently, isn’t quite ready yet.

Clay Shirky, internet theorist and the harbinger-in-chief of newspaper death, encapsulated the problem at a recent Harvard Shorenstein Center talk:

“We are headed into a long trough of decline in accountability journalism because the old models are breaking faster than the new models will be put in their place.”

He’s right. But, intriguingly, he also slings in a caveat. Shirky imagines a time in the future when everything is hunky-dory, and a broad conglomeration of multiple news organisations will ‘overlap and provide a small percentage of journalism individually, but taken as a whole, represent the same position of accountability held by newspapers in the 20th century’.

Perhaps. But until then, we’ve got a problem.

So what’s going to happen in this imminent limbo stage; when journalism enters an intermediate ’state of nature’?

Allow me to imagine…

1) The paywalls go up, and a black market for scoops emerges

Paywalls and micropayment schemes begin to appear on news websites. A few of them make a decent stab of it: News International in particular, as they have a competitive advantage.

As Malcolm Coles at Econsultancy suggests, Murdoch’s sites begin corralling in Sky News, Sky Sports, Fox as well as umpteen other publications and broadcasters that it owns, offering an attractive package behind the wall.

Jason Wilson, writing at NewMatilda.com, suggests that News Corp will ‘draw on its corporate experience with pay television to leverage audiences and money using niche content of various kinds’ kicks in, and, for a while, it all seems to be working.

Desperate to lure readers beyond the paywalls, the organisations that enacted them scramble for scoops. They get dirty. They hunt for drug scandals and nip slips like never before. Investigative journalism becomes feral. They get some real goodies.

Infuriatingly, the exclusives start being screengrabbed and hijacked on pop-up sites.

A black market for scoops emerges,  but readers don’t care if the scoop they are reading is 14th hand and poorly delivered, because they’ve still got it.

Shane Richmond notes in the Telegraph that ‘it doesn’t matter that versions of the story on free sites ‘won’t be as good’ because they’ll be free, which offsets the loss of quality considerably’ (and Google’s Eric Schmidt agrees).
More »

Similar posts:

• Adrian Monck: A response to Clay Shirky on newspaper paywalls
• New York Times: Focus on hyperlocal US news sites
• Media is Social: What the Herald’s new deal says about freelance journalism
• SFGate.com: A suggestion for saving the newspaper industry
• Round-up: Charging for online – Murdoch and the FT

Nieman Journalism Lab: Clay Shirky – Let a thousand flowers bloom to replace newspapers; don’t build a paywall around a public good

The Nieman Journalism Lab has helpfully supplied the audio and a transcript for a talk by Clay Shirky, NYU professor and internet theorist, at the Shorenstein Center on the Press, Politics and Public Policy at Harvard University this week. Shirky looked at social accountability in the context of shifting business models for news.

“I think we are headed into a long trough of decline in accountability journalism, because the old models are breaking faster than the new models can be put into place.”

Full post at this link…

Similar posts:

• Jon Bernstein: Where now for accountability journalism?
• Clay Shirky: ‘Rescuing the reporters’
• Crain’s signs up more than 4,000 to daily news alert
• A journalistic limbo until we reach The New World
• Wired.co.uk: A future without journalists?

Rusbridger on the future of journalism: “I don’t think we would ever go back to having a little pool of elite commentators”

Guardian editor-in-chief Alan Rusbridger’s (@arusbridger) thoughts shared with the web this week:

• Here, in yesterday’s lecture at Queen Mary, University of London, part of the university’s Art Week 2009.

• And a video of Alan Rusbridger at the Institut für Medienpolitik in Berlin on April 22, speaking on the future of journalism and explaining how the Guardian opened up its site to a wider pool of contributors. Some extracts:

“I don’t think we would ever go back to having a little pool of elite commentators, who help appeal to themselves.”

“(…)Bad things are going to happen where newspapers are going to die. There are going to be fewer journalists and the really pricey business of quality journalism is going to require subsidy from somewhere. It’s a broken model.”

On Twitter: “You harness this brilliant pool of knowledge out there. It’s a fantastic marketing tool. It’s a fantastic journalistic tool.”

He says reading Clay Shirky, Adrian Monck, Jeff Jarvis and the Niemen Foundation, via Twitter, is like receiving a personalised wire feed on the world’s press each morning – a service you’d have paid a consultant a lot of money for, in the past.

(NB: We’re glad to note that he’s following @journalismnews too…)

Alan Rusbridger on the Future of Journalism from Carta on Vimeo.

Similar posts:

• Adrian Monck: A response to Clay Shirky on newspaper paywalls
• ‘Why Journalism Matters’ by Alan Rusbridger (@arusbridger): the video
• Press Gazette: Rusbridger says integration of Guardian and Observer will ‘unlock creativity’ of staff
• Alan Rusbridger invites MP Tom Watson to morning conference
• links for 2008-06-25

Adrian Monck: A response to Clay Shirky on newspaper paywalls

Adrian Monck argues against Clay Shirky’s post earlier this week on the broken business model of newspapers, in particular the success of paywalls for financial news sites.

Their survival is ‘based around a professional community, no around the value of information per se’, writes Monck.

Full story at this link…

Similar posts:

• CommentIsFree: Angela Foster on ‘why we still need a black press’
• Editor&Publisher: WaPo and Bloomberg partner for global news wire
• Star News Online: Why news organisations should link to the competition
• Monday Note: Why paid news on mobile could work
• RWW on AdSense and Hitwise on Twitter and retailers

Clay Shirky: The old model’s broken – don’t try to replace it

“‘If the old model is broken, what will work in its place?’ To which the answer is: Nothing. Nothing will work. There is no general model for newspapers to replace the one the internet just broke,” writes Shirky.

The problem that publishing fixed – reducing the cost and difficulty of making information available to the public – has stopped being a problem because of the internet, he adds. As such it’s becoming less relevant to talk about ‘a publishing industry’.

Full post at this link…

Similar posts:

• AOP: Today’s television ‘may not be worth sitting still for’, says US author Clay Shirky
• Adam Westbrook’s guides and an antidote to media navel-gazing
• Tip of the day from Journalism.co.uk – rein in wordy interviewees
• TVWeek: Non-news alternatives for journalists
• FT.com: Threat to democracy by papers’ travails exaggerated

Online Information 2008 kicking off now

Clay Shirky, author of ‘Here Comes Everybody’ is the keynote speaker at Online Information 2008, a conference designed to bring together technology and content. Here’s a preview of Shirky from YouTube (part one. Part Two here):

We’ll keep an eye on the Twitter reports which don’t seem to have started yet – probably on this tag when they do.

Similar posts:

• Little will be keynote speaker at the World Digital Publishing Conference
• Media140: Twitter, newsgathering and trust
• Sneak preview of BBC hyperlocal web service
• 140conf: Follow the event here
• Google Zeitgeist videos: Salman Rushdie, Chad Hurley, Gordon Brown, Will Lewis, Eric Schmidt, Larry Page, Sergey…many more

AOP: Today’s television ‘may not be worth sitting still for’, says US author Clay Shirky

Even children can’t concentrate on television anymore, says Clay Shirky, the US-based internet educator, consultant and author of ‘Here comes Everybody: The Power of Organizing Without Organizations’.

In his speech at yesterday’s AOP Digital Publishing summit Shirky told an anecdote about the four-year-old daughter of one of his friends watching a film: “[S]he jumps round behind the TV and [starts] rooting around in the wires, looking for the mouse.”

Today’s television ‘may not be worth sitting still for’, but the computer is for everything.

The problem for media professionals is that the industry still holds the perception that everyone sees publishing in the same way, he explained.

But, he said, citing the example of Flickr, material may be ‘in public but [it's] not for the public. The cost of putting something out in public has fallen so low.’

“This is a reversal of the usual pattern,” he said. ‘Gather and share has been the usual pattern [of publishing] since time immemorial’, but now grouping comes first.

He split his talk into three categories: the sharing culture of Flickr; the collaborative nature of Wikipedia; and the collective action of internet groupings, citing the use of a Facebook group to force HSBC to reverse its decision on withdrawing students’ interest-free overdrafts.

These examples, he said, show the ‘the environment that’s coming’ and a need to re-think the model’.

“If you wait to hear what the business model is you will hear that your competitors have perfected it,” he said.

Shirky compared today’s media trends to London’s 17th-century gin craze: at first people didn’t know what to do with what they were consuming, but they then learnt how to share, collaborate and collect.

“The action is where people are going after the consumers. Not just consuming, but producing and sharing.”

Similar posts:

• Clay Shirky: The old model’s broken – don’t try to replace it
• Clay Shirky: ‘Rescuing the reporters’
• Social Media Journalist: “Facebook is overrated. The novelty is wearing off and people are getting bored” Matthew Buckland
• Nieman Journalism Lab: Clay Shirky – Let a thousand flowers bloom to replace newspapers; don’t build a paywall around a public good
• Flickr: Inspirational infographics from Good.is