Browse > Home / Newspapers, Online Journalism, comment / Blog article: Jan Moir denies column is homophobic; criticises ‘mischievous’ and ‘heavily orchestrated internet campaign’

| Subscribe via EMAIL | Or RSS

Jan Moir denies column is homophobic; criticises ‘mischievous’ and ‘heavily orchestrated internet campaign’

October 16th, 2009Posted by Judith Townend in Newspapers, Online Journalism, comment

The Daily Mail has released a statement from their columnist, Jan Moir, about her Stephen Gately article, originally titled ‘Why there was nothing ‘natural’ about Stephen Gately’s death’ that is unlikely to appease her critics.

Journalism.co.uk is reproducing some of its contents here, but that is by no means an endorsement of her response. For a full background on the complaints and criticism Moir received see this post by Roy Greenslade on Media Guardian and this article on New Media Age.

The Mail has pulled the advertising around the story, NMA reports.

“Some people, particularly in the gay community, have been upset by my article about the sad death of Boyzone member Stephen Gately. This was never my intention. Stephen, as I pointed out in the article was a charming and sweet man who entertained millions,” Moir said.

“However, the point of my column – which, I wonder how many of the people complaining have fully read – was to suggest that, in my honest opinion,  his death raises many unanswered questions,” she goes on.

Moir then again speculates about facts surrounding his death; Journalism.co.uk will leave it to someone else to publish that part.

“The entire matter of his sudden death seemed to have been handled with undue haste when lessons could have been learned. On this subject, one very  important point,” she squirms.

“When I wrote that ‘he would want to set an example to any  impressionable young men who may want to emulate what they might see as his glamorous routine’ … [More allegations follow].

And squirms:

“Not to the fact of his homosexuality.  In writing that ‘it strikes another blow to the happy-ever-after myth of civil partnerships’ I was suggesting that civil partnerships – the introduction of which I am on the record in supporting – have proved just to be as problematic as marriages.”

There’s more:

“In what is clearly a heavily orchestrated internet campaign I think it is mischievous in the extreme to suggest that my article has homophobic and bigoted undertones.”

Similar posts:

8 Responses to “Jan Moir denies column is homophobic; criticises ‘mischievous’ and ‘heavily orchestrated internet campaign’”

  1. Liberal Conspiracy » Over 1,000 complain; Mail admits pulling ads Says:

    [...] at Journalism.co.uk · About the author: Chris is a regular contributor to Liberal Conspiracy. He is an aspiring [...]


  2. Over 1,000 complain; Mail says it pulled ads from Moir  Says:

    [...] More at Journalism.co.uk [...]


  3. Moir: over 1000 complain; Mail admits pulling ads  Says:

    [...] at Journalism.co.uk Share and [...]


  4. Mail Online confirms withdrawal of ads on Moir article; defends free speech | Journalism.co.uk Editors' Blog Says:

    [...] “As Jan Moir, who has gone on record supporting civil partnerships, says in her statement, this intensely choreographed campaign mischievously misrepresents her carefully argued article. [...]


  5. Comment: The rise of ’smart’ or ‘not so smart’ internet mobs and their pressure on the media | Journalism.co.uk Editors' Blog Says:

    [...] was forced to eat crow the very same day as publication and issued a statement of correction/clarification (you take your pick), claiming complaints against her Daily Mail article were mischievously [...]


  6. Liberal Conspiracy » Civil partnerships are the new Black friends Says:

    [...] broadly speaking, seems to be the impression created by Jan Moir’s weaselling non-apology for Friday’s reprehensible commentary on the untimely death of Stephen Gately. Its certainly [...]


  7. Civil partnerships are the new Black friends  Says:

    [...] broadly speaking, seems to be the impression created by Jan Moir’s weaselling non-apology for Friday’s reprehensible commentary on the untimely death of Stephen [...]


  8. Jan Moir tries to explain herself (again) in new column | Journalism.co.uk Editors' Blog Says:

    [...] who should need little introduction, has used her weekly column in a bid to explain herself again (first attempt here), in the face of over 25,000 complaints to the Press Complaints Commission [...]


Leave a Reply